>>3654696
I didn't play kiseki so i can't comment on it.
But i played Disco Elysium and its not the same, Disco is more like a book and its not cinematic at all, the only common thing between DE and W3 is that both have dialogue with choices.
>you don't like games at all
What makes you assume that? i like a wide variety of games i just happen to enjoy cinematic games in some cases.

Witcher 3 has rpg mechanics like leveling, stats, skill tree, progression and all that stuff, we can't just ignore this fact, its an action rpg, period.
You can argue its rpg side or its gameplay side is shallow and i will agree with you, but its still a rpg.
Within its genre, the cinematic rpg or what you call movie game its imo the undisputed king, only rivaled by mass effect series but even mass effect doesn't reach its level. all other bioware games can't compete, all jrpgs like final fantasy 16 can't compete.

So what is left is that you will compare it to actual movie games, fair, which ones do you think do it better? I can say Death Stranding for example has better cinematics, the cutscenes are better but it has no side quests, no actual worldbuilding at play, its full of boring chores that lead to nowhere.
You can argue with Uncharted or The Last of Us if you want, but i think both are not as good, as Uncharted feels like a cheap copy of Indiana Jones meets Tomb Raider and aside from its shallow third person shooting galleries all it has is some sarcastic lines and beautiful graphics.

Maybe Red Dead 2 is a worthy rival or Metal Gear Solid 3, but like we are talking about the top 5% of cinematic story-driven games here, so how is it bad?
I mean look at the competition, Horizon Zero Dawn? don't think its better.
Maybe Alan Wake 2 is better but its not for everyone and i found the writing in W3 to be superior, but i respect the game.

Back | Go to board

Board:

/vrpg/

Thread:

>combat is worse than both bg2 and divinity 2>somehow its way more popular than bothI don't get it.

>combat is worse than both bg2 and divinity 2
>somehow its way more popular than both
I don't get it.