>>17802517
>um ackshually a vanguard party ISN'T adventurism...
what? this has to be satire. adventurism is in short individual action (terrorism) that will spawn a collective action, but that just never happens.
a vanguard party educates the proletariat on marxism and leads a revolution, hopefully winning. the vanguard is collective action that creates more collective action. why do you think these are the same?

>um ackshually it's not worker democracy unless we destroy the Soviets
i never said this, and i do not support it either. take your normal pills

>Narodnaya Voquaeda had individual men and women with bigger balls of steel than all the BolsheGODS combined
i guess you can argue that it takes more bravery to assasinate the tsar alone than start a revolution with a party by your side. but the fact is that bravery does not mean results, and the narodniks did not achieve any good for the average russian.

>Marx was just retarded, pretending that the Paris Commune could magically create its own structures of rule out of temporary riotous control of a single city.

who is to say that they could not have created a government in that city if it werent for the fact that they were crushed? but anyway, the paris commune attempted to seize the ready made state machinery for itself, but entirely failed both because the regular army stopped them at versailles, and the fact that communism cannot seize a burgeois state and change it to serve itself. a new state in its entirety must be created to serve the dictatorship. marx thought they could seize it before, but after the fact he changed his position after seeing reality in action.

>You can achieve wonderful progress and give all people (not just your tiny worker privileged class) access to the bountiful wealth of the earth without class hierarchy - the SRs would have done just that if (cope)

are you retarded? they were burgeois servants and nothing else. defencist nationalist """socialists""" are just liberals.

Back | Go to board

Board:

/his/

Thread:

If you know someone is a socialist, then one question will clarify any remaining doubts you have about their particular ideology:>When did the…

If you know someone is a socialist, then one question will clarify any remaining doubts you have about their particular ideology:
>When did the…