>>7540999
>being fairly homogenised
>You said it's unrecognizable.
Holy shit. How do you not understand that those are the same criticism? Don't go around attacking other people's intelligence if you're going to spout stupid shit like this.
>You think something highly complex and beyond your understanding and skill level is actually trivial and easy, textbook dunning-kruger overrating your ability due to being unskilled in an area.
So then you are unable to criticise western art, as you are likely unskilled in drawing in those styles, yeah? You better not ever criticised that bland calarts style, because that'd make you a hypocrite.
>Draw more anime.
Not an answer, because you know we're only talking about surface level stuff. The difficulty of drawing the art style has no bearing on the criticisms I leveled against it, nor does it make this a 'deep' conversation
>And thus your """"""critique"""""" is nothing but your subjective experience as a low involvement outsider westerner.
Sorry, did I not eat enough sushi and ramen to be allowed to say I enjoy manga and anime?
Is being a fan of manga and anime not enough for me to be able to critique it, even the most shallow level?
Those are rhetorical questions - you've gotten way too high on your loli piss scented candles if you're going to girl boss this hard and try to lecture me about how I'm not actually a fan of something, because I have a differing opinion on the aesthetics of the medium.
Actually, why do I even care about your definition of insider or outsider? I don't need some fart sniffing snob's opinion on waifus, or on my credibility as a fan, and it was a pathetic non-point against my critique anyway, so fuck off.
I'm an outsider? Yeah, I'm outside of your little mono-minded incestuous circlejerk.

Back | Go to board

Board:

/ic/

Thread:

Seriously, why is the art of most creator-owned american comics generally so ugly?