>>510753147
>no, i'd be a muslim or mormon if i just chose a religion based on the goodies i'd get in the afterlife.
Yet, you nonetheless picked Christianity based on personal feelings. Also, you're suggesting that you'd still be a Christian if there wasn't a heaven supposedly waiting for you? I doubt it.

>>510753147
>>That's incorrect, it's not independent of minds.
>then it's not moral realism.
Neither is your moral appeal to your God then.
>the platonic moral realism and naturalist moral realism views you brought up earlier hold that moral truths are mind-independent.
Is murder, as in unjust killing of another being independent of a mind? I think so, as we all can mostly agree on this definition of murder.

>>510753147
>which one do you hold to?
See
>>510745577

>>510753147
>so you're saying it's not possible for things to be morally right or morally wrong if you don't get any goodies from doing the right thing?
"Goodies" are subjective though. Yet we still benefit off them when doing the right thing. Do we not?
>>510753147
>going back to ignoring your garbage posts
You said that last time. We both know you read my replies regardless

>>510753147
>i may or may not have written a doctoral dissertation on it.
You haven't. Nor do you have a PhD

Back | Go to board

Board:

/pol/

Thread:

Why are atheists so interested in tempting people to judge other people?